A technician explains measurements whilst a scientist explains observations.

Science: empirical or platonic?


I've travelled different countries
Travelled to the furthest lands
Couldn't find nobody could tell me
What is the soul of a man
Blind Willie Johnson


The conventional idea of science is that scientists have hypotheses, design experiments to test these hypotheses and then, if the experiments do not show that the hypotheses are wrong they say that they have a "scientific theory".

To some extent this is true but what often happens in the lab is that the boss buys a new piece of equipment that few people have used before and the scientists point this bit of kit at anything that takes their fancy. The observations are new so the lab can publish loads of papers, occasionally linking their observations to current theories. This doesn't just happen with new instruments, for instance, in a drug company the chemists are making thousands of new substances and the biological scientists screen these. If one of the chemicals cures a disease they publish the story of their work.

Scientific progress is often about observation with a bit of theory at the back of things. Even the theories are usually empirical in the sense that they do not reach back into the fundamentals of quantum theory and relativity but instead describe how sets of observations fit together. For example, the theories about the human immune system are incredibly complex but actually summarise thousands of observations. They are Empirical Theories.

Usually it is the other sort of theory that grabs the headlines, the non-empirical Platonic Theories. Platonic Theories start from simple assumptions about space, time and matter and attempt to explain the world in terms of the mathematics of these simple building blocks. 90% of working scientists know little about the inner workings of these Platonic Theories and don't need to know about them to do their job. An ecologist is interested in how the changing fly population affects the local frogs, not the quantum mechanical basis of fly capture!

Empirical theories differ from Platonic theories because the former are really just descriptions of the world whereas the latter are a set of absolute rules. Empirical theories are recipes for retrieving observations or repeating a set of events. There is normally an implication that the empirical theory will apply if the conditions of the original observations that gave rise to the empirical theory are present. This limited scope means that empirical theories can only be invalidated by demonstrating that the original observations were dishonest. In contrast, in science, Platonic theories are invalidated if there are any circumstances in which they are contradicted by empirical observation.

Science is largely an empirical art, it is the art of observation and description. The inferences that go between the observations are interesting but frequently of secondary importance.

The Platonic and empirical collide where there are deeply held convictions about Platonic theories. The most obvious example of this is the "mind". The empirical description of the mind is that it is like a set of things laid out around an observation point (Descartes' "res cogitans", the unextended viewing point). Look around, imagine things or have a day dream, see, the mind is like this. Nineteenth century Platonic theories of physics cannot explain such an observation so those Platonists who use nineteenth century ideas deny that the mind exists (and the Dualists say that the mind obviously exists so "science" is wrong).


We know that we have minds, just look, but if we believe strongly enough in nineteenth century Platonic theories of physics we can persuade ourselves that these minds do not exist.  The fact that theories can be created is wonderful but if they contradict or forbid observation they are of limited applicability or wrong and are certainly not scientific.

8 comments:

  1. I like this essay. Bottom line -- science is a pragmatic enterprise.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Arnold - it is a beautiful way forward for progress and discovery.

    ReplyDelete
  3. #All thanks to Mr Anderson for helping with my profits and making my fifth withdrawal possible. I'm here to share an amazing life changing opportunity with you. its called Bitcoin / Forex trading options. it is a highly lucrative business which can earn you as much as $2,570 in a week from an initial investment of just $200. I am living proof of this great business opportunity. If anyone is interested in trading on bitcoin or any cryptocurrency and want a successful trade without losing notify Mr Anderson now.Whatsapp: (+447883246472 )
    Email: tdameritrade077@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Do you need a quick loan?
    Have you been denied a bank loan?
    Do you need a loan during this pandemic?
    interest rate of 2% no matter your location
    Do you need a loan to solve your financial problems?
    If so, then you are in luck because my company lends for a short time and the interest rate is low. If you are interested, Kindly reply to us at (Whats App) number:+919394133968
    patialalegitimate515@gmail.com Mr Jeffery.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Investing online has been a main source of income, that’s why knowledge plays a very important role in humanity, you don’t need to over work yourself for money.All you need is the right information, and you could build your own wealth from the comfort of your home!Binary trading is dependent on timely signals, assets or controlled strategies which when mastered increases chance of winning up to 90%-100% with trading. It’s possible to earn $10,000 to $20,000 trading weekly-monthly in cryptocurrency(bitcoin) investment,just file a complaint with my broker Mr. Carlos Wilfred. I had almost given up on everything about binary trading and never getting my lost funds back, till i met with him, with his help and guidance now i have my lost funds back to my bank account, gained more profit and I can now trade successfully with his profitable strategies and software!! Email: investandearnbinaryfx@gmail.com or whatsApp: +1(424)285-0682 or telegram: @IEBINARYFX for inquiries.

    ReplyDelete
  6. My name is Mohammed Ahsan I'm a financial Consultant of a reputable firm Operating out of the United Kingdom
    we provide Discrete Financial, Services for High Net Worth CEO's/Executives of Corporation & Senior Government Officials globally.
    What we do is Legal & within the ambit of the law but following the Leakage of the Infamous United Kingdom
    Papers & subsequent threat by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ)
    International Criminal Court (ICC)
    Below is what my Sender can offer.
    1, MT103 gpi automatic
    2, MT103 wire transfer
    3, MT103 TT
    4, MT103/202 manual download
    5, SBLC lease and Purchase

    All bank instrument will be done via bank officer to bank officer, Receiver has to provide bank officer details
    on DOA all brokers are welcome and guarantee of there payment after successful deal
    kindly send me a message via email and WhatsApp.


    Email: mohammedahsan877@gmail.com

    WhatsApp- +19893413179

    ReplyDelete
  7. Where can I find the best Bitcoin private keys? http://allcryptosoftware.net/

    ReplyDelete
  8. Bitcoin is a digital currency. It is basically a computer file which is stored in a "digital wallet '' app on a smart phone or computer. People can send Bitcoin (or part of one) to your digital wallet, and you can send Bitcoins to other people. You can simply earn bitcoin by mining but it takes lot of time. The best way to earn Bitcoin now is by investing little amount of bitcoin and get 5%, 7% and 25%. And you can simply withdraw to your bank account any day and anytime . visit alphabitmining.com


    Is it legal to buy cryptocurrency in USA? alphabitmining.com
    Which crypto exchange is best in USA? alphabitmining.com
    Can you get rich investing in cryptocurrency? alphabitmining.com
    Which cryptocurrency is best to invest? alphabitmining.com
    Which Cryptocurrency should I buy for future? alphabitmining.com
    What will bitcoin be worth by 2022? alphabitmining.com
    new crypto coins 2022 alphabitmining.com
    is bitcoin a good investment 2022 alphabitmining.com
    What will bitcoin be worth by 2022? alphabitmining.com
    ethereum price prediction 2022 alphabitmining.com
    bitcoin price prediction 2023 alphabitmining.com
    bitcoin price prediction 2025 alphabitmining.com
    best cryptocurrency to invest in 2022 for long-term alphabitmining.com
    best upcoming cryptocurrency 2022 alphabitmining.com
    most promising cryptocurrency 2022 alphabitmining.com
    new upcoming cryptocurrency 2022 alphabitmining.com
    top cryptocurrency predictions 2022 alphabitmining.com
    best crypto to invest 2022 alphabitmining.com
    best cryptocurrency to buy 2022 alphabitmining.com
    upcoming cryptocurrency 2022 alphabitmining.com
    best crypto to buy 2022 alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 news alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 schedule alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 chart alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 calendar alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 review alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 performance alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 date alphabitmining.com
    cryptocurrency investment 2022 strategy alphabitmining.com

    ReplyDelete